1503 lines
67 KiB
Plaintext
1503 lines
67 KiB
Plaintext
From ai815@freenet.carleton.caMon Aug 21 11:10:57 1995
|
|
Date: Wed, 26 Jul 1995 05:19:52 -0400
|
|
From: Greg Erwin <ai815@freenet.carleton.ca>
|
|
To: kris.taylor@smorgasboard.org, lloydk@teleport.com, gerryu@delphi.com
|
|
Subject: August 1995 Nullifidian
|
|
|
|
############################################################
|
|
############################################################
|
|
______
|
|
/ / / /
|
|
/ /__ __
|
|
/ / ) (__
|
|
/ / (__(__
|
|
|
|
__
|
|
|\ ( ) ) / /
|
|
| \ | / / . _/_ . __ / . __ __
|
|
| \ | / / / / ) / ) / / ) __ ) / )
|
|
) \| (__(__(___(__(__(___(__(__(__(__(__(__/ (__
|
|
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
*The*E-Zine*of*Atheistic*Secular*Humanism*and*Freethought**
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
|
|
############################################################
|
|
###### Volume II, Number 8 ***A Collector's Item!***#####
|
|
################### ISSN 1201-0111 #######################
|
|
####################### AUG 1995 ###########################
|
|
|
|
nullifidian, n. & a. (Person) having no religious faith or
|
|
belief. [f. med. L _nullifidius_ f. L _nullus_ none +
|
|
_fides_ faith; see -IAN] Concise Oxford Dictionary
|
|
|
|
The purpose of this magazine is to provide a source of
|
|
articles dealing with many aspects of humanism.
|
|
|
|
We are ATHEISTIC as we do not believe in the actual
|
|
existence of any supernatural beings or any transcendental
|
|
reality.
|
|
|
|
We are SECULAR because the evidence of history and the daily
|
|
horrors in the news show the pernicious and destructive
|
|
consequences of allowing religions to be involved with
|
|
politics or government.
|
|
|
|
We are HUMANISTS and we focus on what is good for humanity,
|
|
in the real world. We will not be put off with offers of
|
|
pie in the sky, bye and bye.
|
|
|
|
Re: navigation.
|
|
|
|
Search for BEG to find the beginning of the next article.
|
|
Search for the first few words of the title as given in the
|
|
table of contents to find a specific article. I try to
|
|
remember to copy the title from the text and then paste it
|
|
into the ToC, so it should be exact. Search for "crass
|
|
commercialism:" to see what's for sale. Subscription
|
|
information, etc is at the end of the magazine, search for
|
|
END OF TEXTS.
|
|
############################################################
|
|
############################################################
|
|
============================================================
|
|
/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\
|
|
TABLE OF CONTENTS
|
|
|
|
1. THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH. R.G. Ingersoll
|
|
|
|
2. The Harm Caused by Religion -- annotated bibliography
|
|
compiled by Wendell Watters, MD.
|
|
|
|
3. Infomercial and Poem, (Anti-creationist materials
|
|
from Dennis L. Matson)
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
|| BEGINNING OF ARTICLE ||
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
29 page printout
|
|
|
|
Reproducible Electronic Publishing can defeat censorship.
|
|
|
|
**** ****
|
|
|
|
THE DIVIDED HOUSEHOLD OF FAITH.
|
|
|
|
1888
|
|
|
|
"Let determined things to destiny hold unbewailed their
|
|
way."
|
|
|
|
There is a continual effort in the mind of man to find
|
|
the harmony that he knows must exist between all known
|
|
facts. It is hard for the scientist to implicitly believe
|
|
anything that he suspects to be inconsistent with a known
|
|
fact. He feels that every fact is a key to many mysteries --
|
|
that every fact is a detective, not only, but a perpetual
|
|
witness. He knows that a fact has a countless number of
|
|
sides, and that all these sides will match all other facts,
|
|
and he also suspects that to understand one fact perfectly
|
|
-- like the fact of the attraction of gravitation -- would
|
|
involve a knowledge of the universe.
|
|
|
|
It requires not only candor, but courage, to accept a
|
|
fact. When a new fact is found -- it is generally denied,
|
|
resisted, and calumniated by the conservatives until denial
|
|
becomes absurd, and then they accept it with the statement
|
|
that they always supposed it was true.
|
|
|
|
The old is the ignorant enemy of the new. The old has
|
|
pedigree and respectability; it is filled with the spirit of
|
|
caste; it is associated with great events, and with great
|
|
names; it is entrenched; it has an income -- it represents
|
|
property. Besides, it has parasites, and the parasites
|
|
always defend themselves,
|
|
|
|
Long ago frightened wretches who had by tyranny or
|
|
piracy amassed great fortunes, were induced in the moment of
|
|
death to compromise with God and to let their money fall
|
|
from their stiffening hands into the greedy palms of
|
|
priests. In this way many theological seminaries were
|
|
endowed, and in this way prejudices, mistakes, absurdities,
|
|
known as religious truths, have been perpetuated. In this
|
|
way the dead hypocrites have propagated and supported their
|
|
kind.
|
|
|
|
Most religions -- no matter how honestly they
|
|
originated -- have been established by brute force. Kings
|
|
and nobles have used them as a means to enslave, to degrade
|
|
and rob. The priest, consciously and unconsciously, has been
|
|
the betrayer of his followers.
|
|
|
|
Near Chicago there is an ox that betrays his fellows.
|
|
Cattle -- twenty or thirty at a time -- are driven to the
|
|
place of slaughter. This ox leads the way -- the others
|
|
follow. When the place is reached, this Bishop Dupanloup
|
|
turns and goes back for other victims.
|
|
|
|
This is the worst side: There is a better.
|
|
|
|
Honest men, believing that they have found the whole
|
|
truth -- the real and only faith -- filled with enthusiasm,
|
|
give all for the purpose of propagating the "divine creed."
|
|
They found colleges and universities, and in perfect, pious,
|
|
ignorant sincerity, provide that the creed, and nothing but
|
|
the creed, must be taught, and that if any professor teaches
|
|
anything contrary to that, he must be instantly dismissed --
|
|
that is to say, the children must be beaten with the bones
|
|
of the dead.
|
|
|
|
These good religious souls erect guide-boards with a
|
|
provision to the effect that the guide-boards must remain,
|
|
whether the roads are changed or not, and with the further
|
|
provision that the professors who keep and repair the
|
|
guide-boards must always insist that the roads have not been
|
|
changed.
|
|
|
|
There is still another side.
|
|
|
|
Professors do not wish to lose their salaries. They
|
|
love their families and have some regard for themselves.
|
|
There is a compromise between their bread and their brain.
|
|
On pay-day they believe -- at other times they have their
|
|
doubts, They settle with their own consciences by giving old
|
|
words new meanings. They take refuge in allegory, hide
|
|
behind parables, and barricade themselves with oriental
|
|
imagery. They give to the most frightful passages a
|
|
spiritual meaning -- and while they teach the old creed to
|
|
their followers, they speak a new philosophy to their
|
|
equals.
|
|
|
|
There is still another side.
|
|
|
|
A vast number of clergymen and laymen are perfectly
|
|
satisfied. They have no doubts. They believe as their
|
|
fathers and mothers did. The "scheme of salvation" suits
|
|
them because they are satisfied that they are embraced
|
|
within its terms. They give themselves no trouble. They
|
|
believe because they do not understand. They have no doubts
|
|
because they do not think. They regard doubt as a thorn in
|
|
the pillow of orthodox slumber. Their souls are asleep, and
|
|
they hate only those who disturb their dreams. These people
|
|
keep their creeds for future use. They intend to have them
|
|
ready at the moment of dissolution. They sustain about the
|
|
same relation to daily life that the small boats carried by
|
|
steamers do to ordinary navigation -- they are for the
|
|
moment of shipwreck. Creeds, like life- preservers, are to
|
|
be used in disaster.
|
|
|
|
We must also remember that everything in nature -- bad
|
|
as well as good -- has the instinct of self-preservation.
|
|
All lies go armed, and all mistakes carry concealed weapons.
|
|
Driven to the last corner, even non-resistance appeals to
|
|
the dagger.
|
|
|
|
Vast interests -- political, social, artistic, and
|
|
individual -- are interwoven with all creeds. Thousands of
|
|
millions of dollars have been invested; many millions of
|
|
people obtain their bread by the propagation and support of
|
|
certain religious doctrines, and many millions have been
|
|
educated for that purpose and for that alone. Nothing is
|
|
more natural than that they should defend themselves -- that
|
|
they should cling to a creed that gives them roof and
|
|
raiment.
|
|
|
|
Only a few years ago Christianity was a complete
|
|
system. It included and accounted for all phenomena; it was
|
|
a philosophy satisfactory to the ignorant world; it had an
|
|
astronomy and geology of its own; it answered all questions
|
|
with the same readiness and the same inaccuracy; it had
|
|
within its sacred volumes the history of the past, and the
|
|
prophecies of all the future; it pretended to know all that
|
|
was, is, or ever will be necessary for the well-being of the
|
|
human race, here and hereafter,
|
|
|
|
When a religion has been founded, the founder admitted
|
|
the truth of everything that was generally believed that did
|
|
not interfere with his system. Imposture always has a
|
|
definite end in view, and for the sake of the accomplishment
|
|
of that end, it will admit the truth of anything and
|
|
everything that does not endanger its success.
|
|
|
|
The writers of all sacred books -- the inspired
|
|
prophets -- had no reason for disagreeing with the common
|
|
people about the origin of things, the creation of the
|
|
world, the rising and setting of the sun, and the uses of
|
|
the stars, and consequently the sacred books of all ages
|
|
have indorsed the belief general at the time. You will find
|
|
in our sacred books the astronomy, the geology, the
|
|
philosophy and the morality of the ancient barbarians. The
|
|
religionist takes these general ideas as his foundation, and
|
|
upon them builds the supernatural structure. For many
|
|
centuries the astronomy, geology, philosophy and morality of
|
|
our Bible were accepted. They were not questioned, for the
|
|
reason that the world was too ignorant to question.
|
|
|
|
A few centuries ago the art of printing was invented. A
|
|
new world was discovered. There was a complete revolution in
|
|
commerce. The arts were born again. The world was filled
|
|
with adventure; millions became self-reliant; old ideas were
|
|
abandoned -- old theories were put aside -- and suddenly,
|
|
the old leaders of thought were found to be ignorant,
|
|
shallow and dishonest. The literature of the classic world
|
|
was discovered and translated into modern languages. The
|
|
world was circumnavigated; Copernicus discovered the true
|
|
relation sustained by our earth to the solar system, and
|
|
about the beginning of the seventeenth century many other
|
|
wonderful discoveries were made. In 1609, a Hollander found
|
|
that two lenses placed in a certain relation to each other
|
|
magnified objects seen through them. This discovery was the
|
|
foundation of astronomy. In a little while it came to the
|
|
knowledge of Galileo; the result was a telescope, with
|
|
which man has read the volume of the skies.
|
|
|
|
On the 8th day of May, 1618, Kepler discovered the
|
|
greatest of his three laws. These were the first great blows
|
|
struck for the enfranchisement of the human mind. A few
|
|
began to suspect that the ancient Hebrews were not
|
|
astronomers. From that moment the church became the enemy of
|
|
science. In every possible way the inspired ignorance was
|
|
defended -- the lash, the sword, the chain, the fagot and
|
|
the dungeon were the arguments used by the infuriated
|
|
church.
|
|
|
|
To such an extent was the church prejudiced against the
|
|
new philosophy, against the new facts, that priests refused
|
|
to look through the telescope of Galileo.
|
|
|
|
At last it became evident to the intelligent world that
|
|
the inspired writings, literally translated, did not contain
|
|
the truth -- the Bible was in danger of being driven from
|
|
the heavens.
|
|
|
|
The church also had its geology. The time when the
|
|
earth was created had been definitely fixed and was
|
|
certainly known. This fact had not only been stated by
|
|
inspired writers, but their statement had been indorsed by
|
|
priests, by bishops, cardinals, popes and ecumenical
|
|
councils; that was settled.
|
|
|
|
But a few men had learned the art of seeing. There were
|
|
some eyes not always closed in prayer. They looked at the
|
|
things about them; they observed channels that had been worn
|
|
in solid rock by streams; they Saw the vast territories that
|
|
had been deposited by rivers; their attention was called to
|
|
the slow inroads upon continents by seas -- to the deposits
|
|
by volcanoes -- to the sedimentary rocks -- to the vast
|
|
reefs that had been built by the coral, and to the countless
|
|
evidences of age, of the lapse of time -- and finally it was
|
|
demonstrated that this earth had been pursuing its course
|
|
about the sun for millions and millions of ages.
|
|
|
|
The church disputed every step, denied every fact,
|
|
resorted to every device that cunning could suggest or
|
|
ingenuity execute, but the conflict could not be maintained.
|
|
The Bible, so far as geology was concerned, was in danger of
|
|
being driven from the earth.
|
|
|
|
Beaten in the open field, the church began to
|
|
equivocate, to evade, and to give new meanings to inspired
|
|
words. Finally, falsehood having failed to harmonize the
|
|
guesses of barbarians with the discoveries of genius, the
|
|
leading churchmen suggested that the Bible was not written
|
|
to teach astronomy, was not written to teach geology, and
|
|
that it was not a scientific book, but that it was written
|
|
in the language of the people, and that as to unimportant
|
|
things it contained the general beliefs of its time.
|
|
|
|
The ground was then taken that, while it was not
|
|
inspired in its science, it was inspired in its morality, in
|
|
its prophecy, in its account of the miraculous, in the
|
|
scheme of salvation, and in all that it had to say on the
|
|
subject of religion.
|
|
|
|
The moment it was suggested that the Bible was not
|
|
inspired in everything within its lids, the seeds of
|
|
suspicion were sown. The priest became less arrogant. The
|
|
church was forced to explain. The pulpit had one language
|
|
for the faithful and another for the philosophical, i.e., it
|
|
became dishonest with both.
|
|
|
|
The next question that arose was as to the origin of
|
|
man.
|
|
|
|
The Bible was being driven from the skies. The
|
|
testimony of the stars was against the sacred volume. The
|
|
church had also been forced to admit that the world was not
|
|
created at the time mentioned in the Bible -- so that the
|
|
very stones of the earth rose and united with the stars in
|
|
giving testimony against the sacred volume.
|
|
|
|
As to the creation of the world, the church resorted to
|
|
the artifice of saying that "days" in reality meant long
|
|
periods of time; so that no matter how old the earth was,
|
|
the time could be spanned by six periods -- in other words,
|
|
that the years could not be too numerous to be divided by
|
|
six.
|
|
|
|
But when it came to the creation of man, this evasion,
|
|
or artifice, was impossible. The Bible gives the date of the
|
|
creation of man, because it gives the age at which the first
|
|
man died, and then it gives the generations from Adam to the
|
|
flood, and from the flood to the birth of Christ, and in
|
|
many instances the actual age of the principal ancestor is
|
|
given. So that, according to this account -- according to
|
|
the inspired figures -- man has existed upon the earth only
|
|
about six thousand years. There is no room left for any
|
|
people beyond Adam.
|
|
|
|
If the Bible is true, certainly Adam was the first man;
|
|
consequently, we know, if the sacred volume be true, just
|
|
how long man has lived and labored and suffered on this
|
|
earth.
|
|
|
|
The church cannot and dare not give up the account of
|
|
the creation of Adam from the dust of the earth, and of Eve
|
|
from the rib of the man. The church cannot give up the story
|
|
of the Garden of Eden -- the serpent -- the fall and the
|
|
expulsion; these must be defended because they are vital.
|
|
Without these absurdities, the system known as Christianity
|
|
cannot exist. Without the fall, the atonement is a non
|
|
sequitur. Facts bearing upon these questions were discovered
|
|
and discussed by the greatest and most thoughtful of men.
|
|
Lamarck, Humboldt, Haeckel, and above all, Darwin, not only
|
|
asserted, but demonstrated, that man is not a special
|
|
creation. If anything can be established by observation, by
|
|
reason, then the fact has been established that man is
|
|
related to all life below him -- that he has been slowly
|
|
produced through countless years -- that the story of Eden
|
|
is a childish myth -- that the fall of man is an infinite
|
|
absurdity.
|
|
|
|
If anything can be established by analogy and reason,
|
|
man has existed upon the earth for many millions of ages. We
|
|
know now, if we know anything, that people not only existed
|
|
before Adam, but that they existed in a highly civilized
|
|
state; that thousands of years before the Garden of Eden was
|
|
planted men communicated to each other their ideas by
|
|
language, and that artists clothed the marble with thoughts
|
|
and passions.
|
|
|
|
This is a demonstration that the origin of man given in
|
|
the Old Testament is untrue -- that the account was written
|
|
by the ignorance, the prejudice and the egotism of the olden
|
|
time.
|
|
|
|
So, if anything outside of the senses can be known, we
|
|
do know that civilization is a growth -- that man did not
|
|
commence a perfect being, and then degenerate, but that from
|
|
small beginnings he has slowly risen to the intellectual
|
|
height he now occupies.
|
|
|
|
The church, however, has not been willing to accept
|
|
these truths, because they contradict the sacred word. Some
|
|
of the most ingenious of the clergy have been endeavoring
|
|
for years to show that there is no conflict -- that the
|
|
account in Genesis is in perfect harmony with the theories
|
|
of Charles Darwin, and these clergymen in some way manage to
|
|
retain their creed and to accept a philosophy that utterly
|
|
destroys it.
|
|
|
|
But in a few years the Christian world will be forced
|
|
to admit that the Bible is not inspired in its astronomy, in
|
|
its geology, or in its anthropology -- that is to say, that
|
|
the inspired writers knew nothing of the sciences, knew
|
|
nothing of the origin of the earth, nothing of the origin of
|
|
man -- in other words, nothing of any particular value to
|
|
the human race.
|
|
|
|
It is, however, still insisted that the Bible is
|
|
inspired in its morality. Let us examine this question.
|
|
|
|
We must admit, if we know anything, if we feel
|
|
anything, if conscience is more than a word, if there is
|
|
such a thing as right and such a thing as wrong beneath the
|
|
dome of heaven -- we must admit that slavery is immoral. If
|
|
we are honest, we must also admit that the Old Testament
|
|
upholds slavery. It will be cheerfully admitted that Jehovah
|
|
was opposed to the enslavement of one Hebrew by another.
|
|
Christians may quote the commandment "Thou shalt not steal"
|
|
as being opposed to human slavery, but after that
|
|
commandment was given, Jehovah himself told his chosen
|
|
people that they might "buy their bondmen and bondwomen of
|
|
the heathen round about, and that they should be their
|
|
bondmen and their bondwomen forever." So all that Jehovah
|
|
meant by the commandment "Thou shalt not steal" was that one
|
|
Hebrew should not steal from another Hebrew, but that all
|
|
Hebrews might steal from the people of any other race or
|
|
creed.
|
|
|
|
It is perfectly apparent that the Ten Commandments were
|
|
made only for the Jews, not for the world, because the
|
|
author of these commandments commanded the people to whom
|
|
they were given to violate them nearly all as against the
|
|
surrounding people.
|
|
|
|
A few years ago it did not occur to the Christian world
|
|
that slavery was wrong. It was upheld by the church.
|
|
Ministers bought and sold the very people for whom they
|
|
declared that Christ had died. Clergymen of the English
|
|
church owned stock in slave-ships, and the man who denounced
|
|
slavery was regarded as the enemy of morality, and thereupon
|
|
was duly mobbed by the followers of Jesus Christ. Churches
|
|
were built with the results of labor stolen from colored
|
|
Christians. Babes were sold from mothers and a part of the
|
|
money given to send missionaries from America to heathen
|
|
lands with the tidings of great joy. Now every intelligent
|
|
man on the earth, every decent man, holds in abhorrence the
|
|
institution of human slavery.
|
|
|
|
So with the institution of polygamy. If anything on the
|
|
earth is immoral, that is. If there is anything calculated
|
|
to destroy home, to do away with human love, to blot out the
|
|
idea of family life, to cover the hearthstone with serpents,
|
|
it is the institution of polygamy. The Jehovah of the Old
|
|
Testament was a believer in that institution.
|
|
|
|
Can we now say that the Bible is inspired in its
|
|
morality? Consider for a moment the manner in which, under
|
|
the direction of Jehovah, wars were waged. Remember the
|
|
atrocities that were committed. Think of a war where
|
|
everything was the food of the sword. Think for a moment of
|
|
a deity capable of committing the crimes that are described
|
|
and gloated over in the Old Testament. The civilized man has
|
|
outgrown the sacred cruelties and absurdities.
|
|
|
|
There is still another side to this question.
|
|
|
|
A few centuries ago nothing was more natural than the
|
|
unnatural. Miracles were as plentiful as actual events. In
|
|
those blessed days, that which actually occurred was not
|
|
regarded of sufficient importance to be recorded. A religion
|
|
without miracles would have excited derision. A creed that
|
|
did not fill the horizon -- that did not account for
|
|
everything -- that could not answer every question, would
|
|
have been regarded as worthless.
|
|
|
|
After the birth of Protestantism, it could not be
|
|
admitted by the leaders of the Reformation that the Catholic
|
|
Church still had the power of working miracles. If the
|
|
Catholic Church was still in partnership with God, what
|
|
excuse could have been made for the Reformation? The
|
|
Protestants took the ground that the age of miracles had
|
|
passed. This was to justify the new faith. But Protestants
|
|
could not say that miracles had never been performed,
|
|
because that would take the foundation not only from the
|
|
Catholics but from themselves; consequently they were
|
|
compelled to admit that miracles were performed in the
|
|
apostolic days, but to insist that, in their time, man must
|
|
rely upon the facts in nature. Protestants were compelled to
|
|
carry on two kinds of war; they had to contend with those
|
|
who insisted that miracles had never been performed; and in
|
|
that argument they were forced to insist upon the necessity
|
|
for miracles, on the probability that they were performed,
|
|
and upon the truthfulness of the apostles. A moment
|
|
afterward, they had to answer those who contended that
|
|
miracles were performed at that time; then they brought
|
|
forward against the Catholics the same arguments that their
|
|
first opponents had brought against them.
|
|
|
|
This has made every Protestant brain "a house divided
|
|
against itself." This planted in the Reformation the
|
|
irrepressible conflict."
|
|
|
|
But we have learned more and more about what we call
|
|
Nature -- about what we call facts. Slowly it dawned upon
|
|
the mind that force is indestructible -- that we cannot
|
|
imagine force as existing apart from matter -- that we
|
|
cannot even think of matter existing apart from force --
|
|
that we cannot by any possibility conceive of a cause
|
|
without an effect, of an effect without a cause, of an
|
|
effect that is not also a cause. We find no room between the
|
|
links of cause and effect for a miracle. We now perceive
|
|
that a miracle must be outside of Nature -- that it can have
|
|
no father, no mother -- that is to say, that it is an
|
|
impossibility.
|
|
|
|
The intellectual world has abandoned the miraculous.
|
|
Most ministers are now ashamed to defend a miracle. Some try
|
|
to explain miracles, and yet, if a miracle is explained, it
|
|
ceases to exist. Few congregations could keep from smiling
|
|
were the minister to seriously assert the truth of the Old
|
|
Testament miracles.
|
|
|
|
Miracles must be given up. That field must be abandoned
|
|
by the religious world. The evidence accumulates every day,
|
|
in every possible direction in which the human mind can
|
|
investigate, that the miraculous is simply the impossible.
|
|
|
|
Confidence in the eternal constancy of Nature increases
|
|
day by day. The scientist has perfect confidence in the
|
|
attraction of gravitation -- in chemical affinities -- in
|
|
the great fact of evolution, and feels absolutely certain
|
|
that the nature of things will remain forever the same.
|
|
|
|
We have at last ascertained that miracles can be
|
|
perfectly understood; that there is nothing mysterious about
|
|
them; that they are simply transparent falsehoods.
|
|
|
|
The real miracles are the facts in nature, No one can
|
|
explain the attraction of gravitation. No one knows why soil
|
|
and rain and light become the womb of life. No one knows why
|
|
grass grows, why water runs, or why the magnetic needle
|
|
points to the north, The facts in nature are the eternal and
|
|
the only mysteries. There is nothing strange about the
|
|
miracles of superstition, They are nothing but the mistakes
|
|
of ignorance and fear, or falsehoods framed by those who
|
|
wished to live on the labor of others.
|
|
|
|
In our time the champions of Christianity, for the most
|
|
part, take the exact ground occupied by the Deists. They
|
|
dare not defend in the open field the mistakes, the
|
|
cruelties, the immoralities and the absurdities of the
|
|
Bible. They shun the Garden of Eden as though the serpent
|
|
was still there. They have nothing to say about the fall of
|
|
man. They are silent as to the laws upholding slavery and
|
|
polygamy. They are ashamed to defend the miraculous. They
|
|
talk about these things to Sunday schools and to the elderly
|
|
members of their congregations; but when doing battle for
|
|
the faith, they misstate the position of their opponents and
|
|
then insist that there must be a God, and that the soul is
|
|
immortal.
|
|
|
|
We may admit the existence of an infinite Being; we may
|
|
admit the immortality of the soul, and yet deny the
|
|
inspiration of the Scriptures and the divine origin of the
|
|
Christian religion. These doctrines, or these dogmas, have
|
|
nothing in common. The pagan world believed in God and
|
|
taught the dogma of immortality. These ideas are far older
|
|
than Christianity, and they have been almost universal.
|
|
|
|
Christianity asserts more than this. It is based upon
|
|
the inspiration of the Bible, on the fall of man, on the
|
|
atonement, on the dogma of the Trinity, on the divinity of
|
|
Jesus Christ, on his resurrection from the dead, on his
|
|
ascension into heaven.
|
|
|
|
Christianity teaches not simply the immortality of the
|
|
soul -- not simply the immortality of joy -- but it teaches
|
|
the immortality of pain, the eternity of sorrow. It insists
|
|
that evil, that wickedness, that immorality and that every
|
|
form of vice are and must be perpetuated forever. It
|
|
believes in immortal convicts, in eternal imprisonment and
|
|
in a world of unending pain. It has a serpent for every
|
|
breast and a curse for nearly every soul. This doctrine is
|
|
called the dearest hope of the human heart, and he who
|
|
attacks it is denounced as the most infamous of men.
|
|
|
|
Let us see what the church, within a few years, has
|
|
been compelled substantially to abandon, -- that is to say,
|
|
what it is now almost ashamed to defend.
|
|
|
|
First, the astronomy of the sacred Scriptures; second,
|
|
the geology; third, the account given of the origin of man;
|
|
fourth, the doctrine of original sin, the fall of the human
|
|
race; fifth, the mathematical contradiction known as the
|
|
Trinity; sixth, the atonement -- because it was only on the
|
|
ground that man is accountable for the sin of another, that
|
|
he could be justified by reason of the righteousness of
|
|
another; seventh, that the miraculous is either the
|
|
misunderstood or the impossible; eighth, that the Bible is
|
|
not inspired in its morality, for the reason that slavery is
|
|
not moral, that polygamy is not good, that wars of
|
|
extermination are not merciful, and that nothing can be more
|
|
immoral than to punish the innocent on account of the sins
|
|
of the guilty; and ninth, the divinity of Christ.
|
|
|
|
All this must be given up by the really intelligent, by
|
|
those not afraid to think, by those who have the courage of
|
|
their convictions and the candor to express their thoughts.
|
|
What then is left?
|
|
|
|
Let me tell yon, Everything in the Bible that is true,
|
|
is left; it still remains and is still of value. It cannot
|
|
be said too often that the truth needs no inspiration;
|
|
neither can it be said too often that inspiration cannot
|
|
help falsehood. Every good and noble sentiment uttered in
|
|
the Bible is still good and noble. Every fact remains. All
|
|
that is good in the Sermon on the Mount is retained. The
|
|
Lord's Prayer is not affected. The grandeur of self-denial,
|
|
the nobility of forgiveness, and the ineffable splendor of
|
|
mercy are with us still. And besides, there remains the
|
|
great hope for all the human race.
|
|
|
|
What is lost? All the mistakes, all the falsehoods, all
|
|
the absurdities, all the cruelties and all the curses
|
|
contained in the Scriptures. We have almost lost the "hope"
|
|
of eternal pain -- the "consolation" of perdition; and in
|
|
time we shall lose the frightful shadow that has fallen upon
|
|
so many hearts, that has darkened so many lives.
|
|
|
|
The great trouble for many years has been, and still
|
|
is, that the clergy are not quite candid. They are disposed
|
|
to defend the old creed. They have been educated in the
|
|
universities, of the Sacred Mistake -- universities that
|
|
Bruno would call "the widows of true learning." They have
|
|
been taught to measure with a false standard; they have
|
|
weighed with inaccurate scales. in youth, they became
|
|
convinced of the truth of the creed. This was impressed upon
|
|
them by the solemnity of professors who spoke in tones of
|
|
awe. The enthusiasm of life's morning was misdirected. They
|
|
went out into the world knowing nothing of value. They
|
|
preached a creed outgrown. Having been for so many years
|
|
entirely certain of their position, they met doubt with a
|
|
spirit of irritation -- afterward with hatred. They are
|
|
hardly courageous enough to admit that they are wrong.
|
|
|
|
Once the pulpit was the leader -- it spoke with
|
|
authority. By its side was the sword of the state, with the
|
|
hilt toward its hand. Now it is apologized for -- it carries
|
|
a weight. It is now like a living man to whom has been
|
|
chained a corpse. It cannot defend the old, and it has not
|
|
accepted the new. In some strange way it imagines that
|
|
morality cannot live except in partnership with the
|
|
sanctified follies and falsehoods of the past.
|
|
|
|
The old creeds cannot be defended by argument. They are
|
|
not within the circumference of reason -- they are not
|
|
embraced in any of the facts within the experience of man.
|
|
All the subterfuges have been exposed; all the excuses have
|
|
been shown to be shallow, and at last the church must meet,
|
|
and fairly meet, the objections of our time.
|
|
|
|
Solemnity is no longer an argument. Falsehood is no
|
|
longer sacred. People are not willing to admit that mistakes
|
|
are divine. Truth is more important than belief -- far
|
|
better than creeds, vastly more useful than superstitions.
|
|
The church must accept the truths of the present, must admit
|
|
the demonstrations of science, or take its place in the
|
|
mental museums with the fossils and monstrosities of the
|
|
past.
|
|
|
|
The time for personalities has passed; these questions
|
|
cannot be determined by ascertaining the character of the
|
|
disputants; epithets are no longer regarded as arguments;
|
|
the curse of the church produces laughter; theological
|
|
slander is no longer a weapon; argument must be answered
|
|
with argument, and the church must appeal to reason, and by
|
|
that standard it must stand or fall. The theories and
|
|
discoveries of Darwin cannot be answered by the resolutions
|
|
of synods, or by quotations from the Old Testament.
|
|
|
|
The world has advanced. The Bible has remained the
|
|
same. We must go back to the book -- it cannot come to us --
|
|
or we must leave it forever. In order to remain orthodox we
|
|
must forget the discoveries, the inventions, the
|
|
intellectual efforts of many centuries; we must go back
|
|
until our knowledge -- or rather our ignorance -- will
|
|
harmonize with the barbaric creeds.
|
|
|
|
It is not pretended that all the creeds have not been
|
|
naturally produced. It is admitted that under the same
|
|
circumstances the same religions would again ensnare the
|
|
human race. It is also admitted that under the same
|
|
circumstances the same efforts would be made by the great
|
|
and intellectual of every age to break the chains of
|
|
superstition.
|
|
|
|
There is no necessity of attacking people -- we should
|
|
combat error. We should hate hypocrisy, but not the
|
|
hypocrite -- larceny, but not the thief -- superstition, but
|
|
not its victim. We should do all within our power to inform,
|
|
to educate, and to benefit our fellow-men.
|
|
|
|
There is no elevating power in hatred. There is no
|
|
reformation in punishment. The soul grows greater and
|
|
grander in the air of kindness, in the sunlight of
|
|
intelligence.
|
|
|
|
We must rely upon the evidence of our senses, upon the
|
|
conclusions of our reason.
|
|
|
|
For many centuries the church has insisted that man is
|
|
totally depraved, that he is naturally wicked, that all of
|
|
his natural desires are contrary to the will of God. Only a
|
|
few years ago it was solemnly asserted that our senses were
|
|
originally honest, true and faithful, but having been
|
|
debauched by original sin, were now cheats and liars; that
|
|
they constantly deceived and misled the soul; that they were
|
|
traps and snares; that no man could be safe who relied upon
|
|
his senses, or upon his reason; -- he must simply rely upon
|
|
faith; in other words, that the only way for man to really
|
|
see was to put out his eyes.
|
|
|
|
There has been a rapid improvement in the intellectual
|
|
world. The improvement has been slow in the realm of
|
|
religion, for the reason that religion was hedged about,
|
|
defended and barricaded by fear, by prejudice and by law. It
|
|
was considered sacred. It was illegal to call its truth in
|
|
question. Whoever disputed the priest became a criminal;
|
|
whoever demanded a reason, or an explanation, became a
|
|
blasphemer, a scoffer, a moral leper.
|
|
|
|
The church defended its mistakes by every means within
|
|
its power.
|
|
|
|
But in spite of all this there has been advancement,
|
|
and there are enough of the orthodox clergy left to make it
|
|
possible for us to measure the distance that has been
|
|
traveled by sensible people.
|
|
|
|
The world is beginning to see that a minister should be
|
|
a teacher, and that "he should not endeavor to inculcate a
|
|
particular system of dogmas, but to prepare his hearers for
|
|
exercising their own judgments,"
|
|
|
|
As a last resource, the orthodox tell the thoughtful
|
|
that they are not "spiritual" -- that they are "of the
|
|
earth, earthy " -- that they cannot perceive that which is
|
|
spiritual. They insist that "God is a spirit, and must be
|
|
worshipped in spirit."
|
|
|
|
But let me ask, What is it to be spiritual? In order to
|
|
be really spiritual, must a man sacrifice this world for the
|
|
sake of another? Were the selfish hermits, who deserted
|
|
their wives and children for the miserable purpose of saving
|
|
their own little souls, spiritual? Were those who put their
|
|
fellow-men in dungeons, or burned them at the stake on
|
|
account of a difference of opinion, all spiritual people?
|
|
Did John Calvin give evidence of his spirituality by burning
|
|
Servetus? Were they spiritual people who invented and used
|
|
instruments of torture -- who denied the liberty of thought
|
|
and expression -- who waged wars for the propagation of the
|
|
faith? Were they spiritual people who insisted that infinite
|
|
Love could punish his poor, ignorant children forever? Is it
|
|
necessary to believe in eternal torment to understand the
|
|
meaning of the word spiritual? Is it necessary to hate those
|
|
who disagree with you, and to calumniate those whose
|
|
argument you cannot answer, in order to be spiritual? Must
|
|
you hold a demonstrated fact in contempt; must you deny or
|
|
avoid what you know to be true, in order to substantiate the
|
|
fact that you are spiritual?
|
|
|
|
What is it to be spiritual? Is the man spiritual who
|
|
searches for the truth -- who lives in accordance with his
|
|
highest ideal -- who loves his wife and children -- who
|
|
discharges his obligations -- who makes a happy fireside for
|
|
the ones he loves -- who succors the oppressed -- who gives
|
|
his honest opinions -- who is guided by principle -- who is
|
|
merciful and just?
|
|
|
|
Is the man spiritual who loves the beautiful -- who is
|
|
thrilled by music, and touched to tears in the presence of
|
|
the sublime, the heroic and the self-denying? Is the man
|
|
spiritual who endeavors by thought and deed to ennoble the
|
|
human race?
|
|
|
|
The defenders of the orthodox faith, by this time,
|
|
should know that the foundations are insecure.
|
|
|
|
They should have the courage to defend, or the candor
|
|
to abandon. If the Bible is an inspired book, it ought to be
|
|
true. Its defenders must admit that Jehovah knew the facts
|
|
not only about the earth, but about the stars, and that the
|
|
Creator of the universe knew all about geology and astronomy
|
|
even four thousand years ago.
|
|
|
|
The champions of Christianity must show that the Bible
|
|
tells the truth about the creation of man, the Garden of
|
|
Eden, the temptation, the fall and the flood. They must take
|
|
the ground that the sacred book is historically correct;
|
|
that the events related really happened; that the miracles
|
|
were actually performed; that the laws promulgated from
|
|
Sinai were and are wise and just, and that nothing is
|
|
upheld, commanded, indorsed, or in any way approved or
|
|
sustained that is not absolutely right. In other words, if
|
|
they insist that a being of infinite goodness and
|
|
intelligence is the author of the Bible, they must be ready
|
|
to show that it is absolutely perfect. They must defend its
|
|
astronomy, geology, history, miracle and morality.
|
|
|
|
If the Bible is true, man is a special creation, and if
|
|
man is a special creation, millions of facts must have
|
|
conspired, millions of ages ago, to deceive the scientific
|
|
world of to-day.
|
|
|
|
If the Bible is true, slavery is right, and the world
|
|
should go back to the barbarism of the lash and chain. If
|
|
the Bible is true, polygamy is the highest form of virtue.
|
|
If the Bible is true, nature has a master, and the
|
|
miraculous is independent of and superior to cause and
|
|
effect. If the Bible is true, most of the children of men
|
|
are destined to suffer eternal pain. If the Bible is true,
|
|
the science known as astronomy is a collection of mistakes
|
|
-- the telescope is a false witness, and light is a luminous
|
|
liar. If the Bible is true, the science known as geology is
|
|
false and every fossil is a petrified perjurer.
|
|
|
|
The defenders of orthodox creeds should have the
|
|
courage to candidly answer at least two questions: First, Is
|
|
the Bible inspired? Second, Is the Bible true? And when they
|
|
answer these questions, they should remember that if the
|
|
Bible is true, it needs no inspiration, and that if not
|
|
true, inspiration can do it no good.
|
|
|
|
North American Review, August, 1888.
|
|
|
|
END
|
|
|
|
**** ****
|
|
|
|
=========================================================
|
|
|| END OF ARTICLE ||
|
|
=========================================================
|
|
"The time appears to me to have come when it is the duty of
|
|
all to make their dissent from religion known."
|
|
[John Stuart Mill]
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
|| BEGINNING OF ARTICLE ||
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
The Harm Caused by Religion -- annotated bibliography
|
|
|
|
Many humanists feel that we should not attack religion; that
|
|
we should be "pro-human", not "anti-religious", as if these
|
|
two sets of attitudes existed in pure form. Others feel
|
|
that we should learn as much as we can about the real impact
|
|
of Christianity on society and on individual human beings.
|
|
This group of humanists believes that we can only promote
|
|
pro-human attitudes if we understand the depths of the anti-
|
|
human attitudes promoted by centuries of Christian god-talk.
|
|
|
|
These books attempt to enlighten on that point.
|
|
|
|
1. A. Alvarez. _The Savage God: A Study of Suicide_,
|
|
Penguin Books. London. 1974. Originally published by
|
|
Weidenfeld and Nicholson. 1971. 320 pages (See part 2:
|
|
Background)
|
|
|
|
The author traces the history of Christian attitudes toward
|
|
suicide, starting with the suicidal diathesis inherent in
|
|
the martyrdom of Christ and the copy-cat behaviour of the
|
|
early Christians who often went out of their way to invite
|
|
death in order to be united with their Lord. When it became
|
|
apparent that an earthly church would have to be developed,
|
|
this self-destructive behaviour worried the Church fathers,
|
|
notably Augustine. A series of edicts designed to
|
|
discourage voluntary martyrdom was issued, culminating in
|
|
the one issued by the Council of Toledo in 693 AD, in which
|
|
even unsuccessful victims of suicide were threatened with
|
|
excommunication. But since the core doctrine remained
|
|
intact, the suicidal diathesis remains to this day.
|
|
|
|
2. Karen Armstrong. _The Gospel According to Woman:
|
|
Christianity's creation of the sex war in the West_. Elm
|
|
Tree Books. London. 1986. 323 pages.
|
|
|
|
The author, an ex-nun, documents the part played by the
|
|
Christian church in creating the sexist climate from which
|
|
we are now trying to free ourselves. Although Christianity
|
|
did not invent sexism, according to Armstrong, it has been
|
|
more destructive than any other religion in promoting the
|
|
inferior status of women, especially perhaps in placing
|
|
their reproductive capacity at the control of the male god-
|
|
talking establishment.
|
|
|
|
3. Mary Daly. _The Church and the Second Sex_. Beacon
|
|
Press. Boston 1985. 230 pages.
|
|
|
|
Mary Daly, as a Roman Catholic theologian, set out in 1968
|
|
to write a book which attempted to demonstrate that the
|
|
goals of modern feminism were (or could be) compatible with
|
|
the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church. By 1985 she had
|
|
reversed her position one hundred and eighty degrees, and
|
|
wrote a second edition, in which she concluded that "sexism
|
|
was inherent in the symbol system of Christianity itself and
|
|
that a primary function of Christianity in Western culture
|
|
has been to legitimize sexism."
|
|
|
|
4. Rudolph M. Bell. _Holy Anorexia_. The University of
|
|
Chicago Press. Chicago. 1985. 248 pages.
|
|
|
|
Historian Bell has made a startling discovery; the majority
|
|
of female saints in the Roman Catholic church may have been
|
|
anorectic. Of the 261 Italian female saints who lived
|
|
between 1200 AD and the present, the record was incomplete
|
|
in about one third; but of the remaining 170 saints, more
|
|
than half of them displayed clear signs of anorexia. Many
|
|
of them also inflicted all manner of punishments on the
|
|
sinful bodies, including flagellation with chains; and many
|
|
of them died before they were 40, some literally starving
|
|
themselves to death. Among this number were Catherine of
|
|
Siena, Clare of Assisi, and Margaret of Cortona, women who
|
|
were revered for their holiness and who became heroic role
|
|
models for young girls to emulate.
|
|
|
|
5. Edmund D. Cohen. _The Mind of the Bible-Believer_.
|
|
Prometheus Books, Buffalo. 1986. 424 pages.
|
|
|
|
Psychologist Cohen, a survivor of Christian fundamentalism
|
|
himself, analyses the strategies by which these god-talking
|
|
manipulators seduce lonely, troubled human beings.
|
|
Beginning with Device 1 (The Benign Attractive Persona of
|
|
the Bible) and going on to Device 7 (Holy Terror), step by
|
|
step the human intelligence and reasoning powers of the
|
|
victims are eroded to the point where they are persuaded to
|
|
do the same thing to other human beings. Although Cohen is
|
|
talking specifically about the extreme fundamentalist sects,
|
|
the same processes are at work in so-called man-line
|
|
Christianity.
|
|
|
|
6. Abraham Feinberg. _Sex and the Pulpit_. Methuen.
|
|
Toronto. 1981.
|
|
|
|
In this book Rabbi Feinberg explores the Christian approach
|
|
to sexuality, and in a forthright manner, lays bare the real
|
|
motives underlying Christian teachings about sexuality and
|
|
reproductivity. In his own words "The sex drive itself gave
|
|
organized religion an opportunity to amass what was
|
|
indisputably the greatest power ever lodged in human
|
|
hands.". The power was used to wage demographic war on all
|
|
other groups, a war it won since Christianity is numerically
|
|
the largest religion on earth today.
|
|
|
|
7. Reay Tannahill. _Sex in History_. Stein and Day. New
|
|
York. 1980 465 pages.
|
|
|
|
Chapter 6 in this book gives an excellent account of the
|
|
political origins of Christian teachings about sexuality.
|
|
|
|
8. Ludwig Feuerbach. _The Essence of Christianity_. Tr.
|
|
by George Eliot. Prometheus Books. Buffalo. 1989. 340
|
|
pages.
|
|
|
|
This book was originally published in 1841. In it, German
|
|
philosopher Feuerbach promotes the notion that human beings
|
|
invest ordinary concepts with divine meaning and
|
|
significance; in praising God and adhering to Christian
|
|
ideals, we merely reaffirm what is best in ourselves. the
|
|
true danger to humanity occurs when theology acquires the
|
|
force of dogma and doctrine and loses sight of its emergence
|
|
from human nature, as has occurred during most of
|
|
Christianity's existence. In this book Feuerbach takes on
|
|
all aspects of Christian doctrine, including the miracles,
|
|
creation, prayer, the virgin birth, faith, revelation,
|
|
immortality and many others.
|
|
|
|
9. Philip Greven. _Spare the Child_. Alfred A. Knopf.
|
|
New York. 1990. 263 pages.
|
|
|
|
This book explores the religious and secular rationales for
|
|
the physical punishment of children and challenges us to re-
|
|
examine long held assumptions. The author makes the point
|
|
that most of our secular assumptions have roots in the
|
|
religious ones, demonstrating once again that Christian
|
|
teachings have had a profound effect on the entire western
|
|
society, and in their secularized form act on people who
|
|
never darken a church door. He uses many excerpts from
|
|
present-day American Protestant writers to demonstrate that
|
|
violence against children is still being promoted by
|
|
Christian clerics.
|
|
|
|
10. Alice Miller. _For Your Own Good_. The Noonday Press
|
|
(Farrar. Straus. Giroux.) New York 1990. First published
|
|
in German under the title "Am Anfang war Erziehung" (1980).
|
|
tr Hildegarde and Hunter Hannum. 282 pages.
|
|
|
|
Psychoanalyst Miller traces the roots of physical violence
|
|
towards children in the western world to the influence of
|
|
Christianity, as she calls it: "poisonous pedagogy". This
|
|
book should be read in conjunction with Greven's book (#9).
|
|
She illustrates her thesis with, among others, a
|
|
biographical account of Adolf Hitler's early Christian
|
|
childhood.
|
|
|
|
11. Charles W. Sutherland. _Disciples of Destruction: The
|
|
Religious Origins of War and Terrorism_. Prometheus Books.
|
|
Buffalo, New York. 1987. 435 pages.
|
|
|
|
In this book the author outlines the religious roots of war
|
|
and terrorism, citing and indicting Judaism, Islam,
|
|
Christianity and Communism which he sees as a secular
|
|
religion with roots in Christianity. It is a long book with
|
|
some very interesting historical references to back up the
|
|
author's thesis, one that has certainly been reinforced by
|
|
events in Yugoslavia, India, Northern Ireland, Lebanon and
|
|
Africa in recent years.
|
|
|
|
12. Wendell W. Watters MD. _Deadly Doctrine: Health,
|
|
Illness and Christian God-talk_. Prometheus Books, Buffalo,
|
|
New York, 1992. 190 pages.
|
|
|
|
This book which draws on one psychiatrist's experience of 25
|
|
years working with individuals, couples and families,
|
|
demonstrates how many of the points of Christian doctrine,
|
|
by now thoroughly engrained in the wood work of western
|
|
society, are antithetical to the principles of health,
|
|
"mental" as well as "physical" health.
|
|
|
|
13. Albert Ellis. _The Case Against Religion and the Case
|
|
Against Religiosity_. American Atheist Press. P.o. Box
|
|
140195, Austin, TX 87814-0195.
|
|
|
|
Psychotherapist Ellis is a practitioner of Rational Emotive
|
|
Therapy and in the course of his clinical work with patients
|
|
has come to the conclusion that "believers in any kind of
|
|
orthodoxy are distinctly disturbed, since they are obviously
|
|
rigid, fanatic, and dependent individuals. Many liberal
|
|
religionists of various groups are emotionally childish.
|
|
for that is what all manner of religion essentially is:
|
|
childish dependency."
|
|
|
|
14 Joachim Kahl. _The Misery of Christianity (A Plea for a
|
|
Humanity without God)_. Pelican Books. 1972 (tr. from the
|
|
German by N.D. Smith). Harmondsworth, Middlesex, England.
|
|
|
|
An ex-Protestant minister, Kahl analyses the theology of the
|
|
Christian church and, based on his experience as a Christian
|
|
cleric, comes to the conclusion that "theology is a
|
|
parasite, eating at a table which others have set". He
|
|
claims that "man must turn away from seeking refuge in
|
|
illusion and in a morass or unreason: his only salvation is
|
|
in rational thought".
|
|
|
|
15. Dan Barker. _Losing Faith in Faith: From Preacher to
|
|
Atheist_. FFRF (Freedom from Religion Foundation), Madison,
|
|
Wisconsin. 1992.
|
|
|
|
An ex-fundamentalist preacher, the author examines
|
|
Christianity in a penetrating analysis and concludes that
|
|
Christianity is "morally repugnant" and "harmful", and he
|
|
states that "The concepts of original sin, depravity,
|
|
substitutionary forgiveness, intolerance, eternal punishment
|
|
and humble worship are all beneath the dignity of
|
|
intelligent human beings and conflict with the values of
|
|
kindness and reason". He adds, "Religion also poses a
|
|
danger to mental health, damaging self-respect, personal
|
|
responsibility and clarity of thought". This is a book
|
|
every humanist should own.
|
|
|
|
16. Phyllis Graham. _The Jesus Hoax_. Leslie Frewin.
|
|
London. 1974.
|
|
|
|
This former Carmelite nun tells the compelling story of her
|
|
long search for spiritual fulfilment and happiness -- and
|
|
how she eventually found both outside established religion.
|
|
She subsequently discovered that the "teaching" of Jesus,
|
|
"far from being beneficial to humanity, has grievously
|
|
retarded social progress and degraded the level of
|
|
intelligence."
|
|
|
|
17. William Fielding. _Shackles of the Supernatural_
|
|
Vantage Press, Inc. 120 West 31st Street New York, NY 10001
|
|
1969.
|
|
|
|
This is the second edition of a book originally written 30
|
|
years previously by a writer on psychology, sexuality and
|
|
philosophy. In this book he states that supernaturalism
|
|
perpetuates many of the world's evils: war, fanatic
|
|
nationalism, and racial hatreds. He points out that the
|
|
natural world and the supernatural world governed by the
|
|
whims of a deity are as irreconcilable as ever, and that the
|
|
paradox of their co-existence is increasingly untenable to
|
|
more and more thinking people. One of the most enlightening
|
|
points developed in this book is that there is a natural
|
|
ethics governing all animal life, human included, and that
|
|
the development of this natural ethics in individuals is
|
|
seriously compromised by the insertion of the notion that
|
|
morality is derived from supernatural precepts.
|
|
|
|
/*******************************************/
|
|
|
|
In addition to the above books, all humanists would be
|
|
advised to acquaint themselves with 2 books which were very
|
|
influential in promoting the Christian notions that have
|
|
been demonstrated to be so damaging to human beings, notions
|
|
discussed in the above books, and notions from which we are
|
|
trying to free ourselves as the twentieth century draws to a
|
|
close.
|
|
|
|
They are:
|
|
|
|
1. Thomas a Kempis. _The Imitation of Christ_. Moody
|
|
Press. Chicago 1980. 359 pages.
|
|
|
|
Written in 1427 by an Augustinian monk, this book has been
|
|
credited with having as much influence as the Bible in
|
|
spreading Christianity. Readers will be astonished how
|
|
overtly and emphatically believers are warned to avoid human
|
|
contact, to actively seek suffering and to avoid learning if
|
|
they wished to be united with Christ. Self-esteem is
|
|
severely criticised.
|
|
|
|
2. Heinrich Kramer and James Sprenger. The Malleus
|
|
Maleficarum (The Witches' Hammer). Dover Publications. New
|
|
York 1971. 278 pages.
|
|
|
|
The authors were Dominican monks who in 1486 wrote the first
|
|
edition of what become a manual for the subsequent witch
|
|
hunts, accepted by Catholic and Protestant legislatures
|
|
alike for some 300 years. It describes the process of
|
|
demonic possession which afflicted women primarily, men
|
|
being exempt since they were made in the image of the male
|
|
deity! One editor has described this monstrous document as
|
|
"the most important, wisest and weightiest book in the
|
|
world". Sprenger, who himself was responsible for the
|
|
deaths of hundreds of women and girls, is described by the
|
|
same editor as "a mystic of the highest order, a man of most
|
|
saintly life." Enough said.
|
|
|
|
If you plan to look at either of these letter two books,
|
|
pour yourself a double Scotch and have a go. Good luck!
|
|
|
|
Wendell W. Watters, MD
|
|
|
|
ADDENDUM
|
|
|
|
18. C. Daniel Batson and W. Larry Ventis. _The Religious
|
|
Experience: A Social-Psychological Perspective". Oxford
|
|
University Press. New York. 1982.
|
|
|
|
In the early nineteen eighties, psychologist Batson and
|
|
Ventis reviewed the available research literature on three
|
|
questions pertaining to religion: (1) Does religion promote
|
|
"personal freedom or bondage?" (2) Does religion promote
|
|
"mental health or sickness?" (3) Does religion promote
|
|
"Brotherly love or self-concern?" The concluded "There is
|
|
strong evidence that being religious is associated with
|
|
poorer mental health, with greater intolerance of people who
|
|
are different from ourselves, and with no greater concern
|
|
for those in need. This evidence suggests that religion is
|
|
a negative force in human life, and one we would be better
|
|
off without." The subjects were, of course, mainly middle
|
|
class American Christians.
|
|
|
|
=========================================================
|
|
|| END OF ARTICLE ||
|
|
=========================================================
|
|
"Trying to find God is a good deal like looking for money
|
|
one has lost in a dream." [Lemuel K. Washburn, _Is The Bible
|
|
Worth Reading And Other Essays_]
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
|| BEGINNING OF ARTICLE ||
|
|
===========================================================
|
|
Infomercial and Poem, Dennis L. Matson
|
|
|
|
From: "Dennis L. Matson" <72234.330@compuserve.com>
|
|
Subject: Re: Useful material
|
|
|
|
Here is the list of items I'm currently selling:
|
|
|
|
BIBLE ERRORS ($3.80): Here is a handy booklet that attempts
|
|
to make the strongest possible case for biblical error that
|
|
will fit into its 47 pages (5.5 x 8.5). It examines several
|
|
biblical errors in depth even as it develops the concept of
|
|
error, which is where the sophisticated biblicist makes his
|
|
ultimate, slippery stand. Feel free to make a few quality
|
|
copies for your favorite 'enemies.'
|
|
|
|
HOW GOOD ARE THOSE YOUNG-EARTH ARGUMENTS? ($14.50): A
|
|
revised Xerox-book (8.5 x 11) of 103 pages, comb-bound for
|
|
easy Xeroxing of its arguments. It has a plastic cover and
|
|
is attractively laid out. The seven page bibliography gives
|
|
you some idea as to the documentation available in this
|
|
dynamite book, a book which distills the best scientific
|
|
rebuttals I could round up against 30 young-earth arguments,
|
|
some attacks against carbon-14 dating, and some attacks
|
|
against the order and nature of the geologic column. Quite
|
|
a few miscellaneous points, ranging from the philosophy of
|
|
knowledge to objections against teaching evolution, are also
|
|
touched on along with some special topics such as supplying
|
|
the water for Noah's flood, the speed of light, and whether
|
|
mammoths were quick-frozen.
|
|
If you have ever watched a slick creationist in a
|
|
debate, and had the frustration of seeing him get away with
|
|
murder, then you will truly enjoy reading this book. The
|
|
first edition was written to support Ed Babinski in his
|
|
debate with creationist Dr. Kent Hovind.
|
|
For the budget-minded, meaning most of us, I'll make a
|
|
special offer. I'll send you a free copy if you can sell 4
|
|
of these books. If you want the ASCII text on diskette, I
|
|
will consider charging maybe $7.00. If you are connected to
|
|
WWW, you may find a copy floating around for free. However,
|
|
there is no substitute for the physical book; its text,
|
|
tables, and diagrams are beautifully laid out and ready for
|
|
Xeroxing. The diagrams cannot be converted to ASCII.
|
|
|
|
A FEW SEDIMENTARY PROBLEMS FOR NOAH'S FLOOD ($2.00): A 5
|
|
page essay showing the hilarious problems that an asteroid
|
|
impact at Chicxulub presents for Noah's flood. That was the
|
|
impact that probably killed off the dinosaurs.
|
|
|
|
RADIOMETRIC DATING AND WOODMORAPPE'S LIST OF BAD DATES
|
|
($2.00): A 7 page monograph that gives the ultimate answer
|
|
to the creationist tactic of listing bad radiometric dates
|
|
and claiming that the method is no good. A condensed
|
|
version of this work may be found in my Xerox-book listed
|
|
above.
|
|
|
|
A SHORT LIST OF EVOLUTIONARY TRANSITIONAL FORMS ($2.50): A
|
|
12 page whirlwind tour that makes it clear there are plenty
|
|
of intermediate transitional forms. I plan to revise this
|
|
work this year or the next, but it is still devastating.
|
|
ON TAKING THE BIBLE AND NOAH'S FLOOD LITERALLY ($2.00): 7
|
|
pages. A touch of babylonian cosmology and some heavy-duty
|
|
common sense. Rips away at the theological absurdity of
|
|
Noah's Flood.
|
|
|
|
ERRORS OF REASONING ($2.50): A 10 page listing of logical
|
|
and other errors of reasoning. Here is a handy source if you
|
|
want to throw a little Latin into your essays. Each error
|
|
is carefully explained.
|
|
|
|
THE FLOOD ($2.00): A long (but interesting) poem that
|
|
exposes the moral absurdity of Noah's flood.
|
|
|
|
CALCULATING THOSE ODDS ($2.00): A 6 page tour of the major
|
|
pitfalls involved in trying to assign a probability to
|
|
evolution, especially as is done by many creationists. The
|
|
essay is written from a novel perspective, which makes it
|
|
highly readable and fun.
|
|
|
|
DATABASE USE: I maintain a database on 'scientific'
|
|
creationism and biblical error. For a fee of $10.00 I'll
|
|
search 3 specific subjects/names. Within reasonable limits
|
|
I'll try to print out all the references obtained, but if
|
|
there are less than 10 found you will receive credit for
|
|
future searches. For an additional 10 cents per page, I'll
|
|
Xerox any of the sources that I have which are listed.
|
|
(That decision can be made later, after checking your own
|
|
sources.) You might even send me a wish list of
|
|
subjects/names and tell me how much you are willing to
|
|
spend. I'm pretty flexible, so there is no need to worry
|
|
about being zinged by some technicality. For your
|
|
enjoyment, a poem for freethinkers:
|
|
|
|
DOUBT
|
|
The fool cannot doubt;
|
|
he has no mind.
|
|
Poor thing!
|
|
The slave dare not doubt;
|
|
he has no voice.
|
|
Shameful thing!
|
|
The fanatic will not doubt;
|
|
he has no uncertainty.
|
|
Dangerous thing!
|
|
|
|
For the fool---
|
|
guidance.
|
|
For the slave---
|
|
a hammer to break chain.
|
|
For the fanatic---
|
|
doubt!
|
|
|
|
Dare to doubt,
|
|
and you are free.
|
|
Know doubt,
|
|
and you know the beginnings of
|
|
wisdom.
|
|
Attain wisdom,
|
|
and you know how little you really
|
|
know.
|
|
All of which,
|
|
begins with a doubt.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Dave Matson 12/4/90
|
|
Dave Matson
|
|
P.O. Box 61274
|
|
Pasadena, CA 91116
|
|
Best Wishes, Dave Matson
|
|
==========================================================
|
|
|| END OF TEXTS ||
|
|
==========================================================
|
|
"They were allowed to stay there on one condition, and that
|
|
is that they didn't eat of the tree of knowledge. That has
|
|
been the condition of the Christian church from then until
|
|
now. They haven't eaten as yet, as a rule they do not."
|
|
--Clarence Darrow
|
|
|
|
"Everywhere in the world there are ignorance and prejudice,
|
|
but the greatest complex of these, with the most extensive
|
|
prestige and the most intimate entanglement with traditional
|
|
institutions, is the Roman Catholic Church.." [H.G. Wells]
|
|
|
|
'...the Bible as we have it contains elements that are
|
|
scientifically incorrect or even morally repugnant. No
|
|
amount of "explaining away" can convince us that such
|
|
passages are the product of Divine Wisdom.'
|
|
-- Bernard J. Bamberger, _The Story of Judaism_
|
|
|
|
"Atheism is the world of reality, it is reason, it is
|
|
freedom, Atheism is human concern, and intellectual honesty
|
|
to a degree that the religious mind cannot begin to
|
|
understand. And yet it is more than this. Atheism is not an
|
|
old religion, it is not a new and coming religion, in fact
|
|
it is not, and never has been, a religion at all. The
|
|
definition of Atheism is magnificent in its simplicity:
|
|
Atheism is merely the bed-rock of sanity in a world of
|
|
madness."
|
|
ATHEISM: An Affirmative View, by Emmett F. Fields
|
|
=><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|
|| Begging portion of the Zine ||
|
|
==><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><==
|
|
There is no charge for receiving this, and there is no
|
|
charge for distributing copies to any electronic medium.
|
|
Nor is there a restriction on printing a copy for use in
|
|
discussion. You may not charge to do so, and you may not do
|
|
so without attributing it to the proper author and source.
|
|
|
|
If you would like to support our efforts, and help us
|
|
acquire better equipment to bring you more and better
|
|
articles, you may send money to Greg Erwin at: 100,
|
|
Terrasse Eardley / Aylmer, Qc / J9H 6B5 / CANADA. Or buy
|
|
our atheist quote address labels, and other fine products,
|
|
see "Shameless advertising and crass commercialism" below.
|
|
=><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><=
|
|
|| End of Begging portion of the Zine ||
|
|
=><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><====><=
|
|
|
|
Articles will be welcomed and very likely used IF:
|
|
(
|
|
they are emailed to:
|
|
((ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA; or,
|
|
godfree@magi.com), or
|
|
sent on diskette to me at the above Aylmer address in
|
|
any format that an IBM copy of WordPerfect can read;
|
|
) and
|
|
they don't require huge amounts of editing; and
|
|
I like them.
|
|
|
|
I will gladly reprint articles from your magazine, local
|
|
group's newsletter, or original material. There are
|
|
currently about 140 subscribers, plus each issue is posted
|
|
in some newsgroups and is archived as noted elsewhere.
|
|
|
|
If you wish to receive a subscription, email a simple
|
|
request to either address, with a clear request
|
|
for a subscription. It will be assumed that the "Reply
|
|
to:" address is where it is to be sent.
|
|
|
|
We will automate this process as soon as we know how.
|
|
|
|
Yes, please DO make copies! (*)
|
|
|
|
Please DO send copies of The Nullifidian to anyone who might
|
|
be interested.
|
|
|
|
The only limitations are:
|
|
At least clearly indicate the source, and how to subscribe.
|
|
|
|
You do NOT have permission to copy this document for
|
|
commercial purposes.
|
|
|
|
The contents of this document are copyright (c) 1995, Greg
|
|
Erwin (insofar as possible) and are on deposit at the
|
|
National Library of Canada
|
|
|
|
You may find back issues in any place that archives
|
|
alt.atheism. Currently, all back issues are posted at
|
|
the Humanist Association of Ottawa's area on the National
|
|
Capital Freenet. telnet to 134.117.1.22, and enter <go
|
|
humanism> at the "Your choice==>" prompt.
|
|
|
|
ARCHIVES
|
|
Arrangements have been made with etext at umich. ftp to
|
|
etext.umich.edu directory Nullifidian or lucifers-echo.
|
|
|
|
For America On-Line subscribers:
|
|
To access the Freethought Forum on America Online enter
|
|
keyword "Capital", scroll down until you find Freethought
|
|
Forum, double click and you're there. Double click "Files &
|
|
Truth Seeker Articles" and scroll until you find Nullifidian
|
|
files. Double click the file name and a window will open
|
|
giving you the opportunity to display a description of the
|
|
file or download the file.
|
|
|
|
And thanks to the people at the _Truth Seeker_, who edited,
|
|
formatted and uploaded the articles to the aol area.
|
|
/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\
|
|
Shameless advertising and crass commercialism:
|
|
\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/
|
|
Atheistic self-stick Avery(tm) address labels. Consisting
|
|
of 210 different quotes, 30 per page, each label 2 5/8" x
|
|
1". This leaves three 49 character lines available for your
|
|
own address, phone number, email, fax or whatever. Each
|
|
sheet is US$2, the entire set of 7 for US$13; 2 sets for
|
|
US$20. Indicate quantity desired. Print address clearly,
|
|
exactly as desired. Order from address in examples below.
|
|
Laser printed, 8 pt Arial, with occasional flourishes.
|
|
[NOT ACTUAL SIZE]
|
|
<-------------------2 5/8"---------------------->
|
|
_________________________________________________
|
|
|"Reality is that which, when you stop believing |/\
|
|
|in it, doesn't go away." [Philip K. Dick] | |
|
|
|Greg Erwin 100 Terrasse Eardley | 1"
|
|
|Aylmer, Qc J9H 6B5 Canada | |
|
|
| email: ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA | |
|
|
|________________________________________________|\/
|
|
|
|
_________________________________________________
|
|
|"...and when you tell me that your deity made |
|
|
|you in his own image, I reply that he must be |
|
|
|very ugly." [Victor Hugo, writing to clergy] |
|
|
|Greg Erwin 100 Terrasse Eardley |
|
|
|Aylmer, Qc J9H 6B5 Canada Ph: (613) 954-6128 |
|
|
| email: ai815@FreeNet.Carleton.CA |
|
|
|________________________________________________|
|
|
|
|
Other quotes in between the articles are usually part of the
|
|
label quote file. Occasionally I throw in one that is too
|
|
long for a label, but which should be shared.
|
|
|
|
Other stuff for sale:
|
|
|
|
Certificate of Baptism Removal and Renunciation of Religion.
|
|
|
|
Have your baptism removed, renounce religion, and have a
|
|
neat 8" x 11" fancy certificate, on luxury paper, suitable
|
|
for framing, to commemorate the event! Instant eligibility
|
|
for excommunication! For the already baptism-free:
|
|
Certificate of Freedom from Religion. An official atheistic
|
|
secular humanist stamp of approval for only $10! Pamphlet on
|
|
"how to get excommunicated" included FREE with purchase.
|
|
|
|
Poster 8x11: WARNING! This is a religion free zone!
|
|
All religious vows, codes, and commitments are null & void
|
|
herein. Please refrain from contaminating the ideosphere
|
|
with harmful memes through prayer, reverence, holy books,
|
|
proselytizing, prophesying, faith, speaking in tongues or
|
|
spirituality. Fight the menace of second-hand faith!
|
|
Humanity sincerely thanks you!
|
|
Tastefully arranged in large point Stencil on luxury paper.
|
|
|
|
Order from the same address as above.
|
|
/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\_/=\/=\
|
|
============================================================
|
|
Neat books available from H.H. Waldo, Bookseller! Books by
|
|
Ingersoll! Heston's 19th Century Freethought Cartoons!
|
|
|
|
Holy Horrors, An Illustrated History of Religious Murder and
|
|
Madness, by James A. Haught..........................$21.95
|
|
Christian Science, by Mark Twain.....................$15.95
|
|
(reprint of original attack)
|
|
Deadly Doctrine, by Wendell W. Watters, MD...........$27.50
|
|
(Psychological damage caused by Christianity)
|
|
Leaving the Fold, Testimonies of Former
|
|
Fundamentalists, by Edward Babinski..................$32.50
|
|
|
|
and many, many more. Ever changing inventory. Friendly
|
|
letters and news from Robb Marks, Proprietor.
|
|
add $2 postage/handling for first book & 0.50 for each
|
|
additional book. (All prices US$)
|
|
Send 2 first class stamps for H.H. Waldo's current catalog.
|
|
(Use international reply coupon, or get hold of US Stamps)
|
|
TO:
|
|
H.H Waldo, Bookseller
|
|
P.O. Box 350
|
|
Rockton, IL 61072
|
|
or phone 1-800-66WALDO !!!
|
|
tell 'im: "that nullifidian guy sent me!"
|
|
Once again: ISSN: 1201-0111 The Nullifidian Volume Two,
|
|
Number 8: AUGUST 1995.
|
|
|
|
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
|
|
The problem with religions that have all the answers is that
|
|
they don't let you ask the questions.
|
|
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
|
|
(*) There is no footnote, and certainly not an endnote.
|
|
|
|
|
|
--
|
|
It is undoubtedly easier to believe in absolutes, follow blindly, mouth
|
|
received wisdom. ... The question is not whether we could ever achieve a
|
|
humanist equilibrium, but whether we are attempting to achieve it. --John
|
|
Ralson Saul / Greg Erwin, VP, Humanist Association of Canada
|